Local

Want pie for Thanksgiving? Try these 15 Seacoast NH and Maine bakeries

Almost every local bakery in Seacoast New Hampshire and southern Maine makes its version of the favorite classics, and some let their creative culinary muses bake up savory and sweet innovations of this time-honored dessert.

Mercedes Boucher holds up two pies. New Hampshire has many options for those looking for pies for Thanksgiving.
Mercedes Boucher is one of the pie makers at Fogarty's Restaurant in South Berwick, Maine, which has many offerings, as seen Nov. 11, 2026. (USA Today Network)

MMMMMmmmm, pie. Pies of all kinds are available all year long, but somehow they taste better as the traditional dessert after a Thanksgiving feast. Almost every local bakery in Seacoast New Hampshire and southern Maine makes its version of the favorite classics, and some let their creative culinary muses bake up savory and sweet innovations of this time-honored dessert.

Read on for a sampling of whatโ€™s available to order this holiday season on the Seacoast. Some are custard, some are creamy, some are fruity, but whatever you choose, donโ€™t forget to pick up the whipped cream or vanilla ice cream to complement these seasonal delights. 

Mercedes Boucher holds up two pies. New Hampshire has many options for those seeking for pies for Thanksgiving.
Mercedes Boucher is one of the pie makers at Fogarty’s Restaurant in South Berwick, Maine, which has many offerings, as seen Nov. 11, 2026. (USA Today Network)

Fogartyโ€™s Restaurant and Bakery | South Berwick, Maine

Details: 471 Main St., South Berwick, 207-384-8361, fogartysrestaurant.net 

Stop in to the restaurant or call to pre-order your pies for Thanksgiving. There’s an abundance of good choices for pies โ€” apple, blueberry, bumbleberry, key lime, strawberry rhubarb, banana cream, blueberry cream, chocolate cream, coconut cream, lemon cream, pumpkin, strawberry cream, peanut butter, chocolate mousse or chocolate chip cookie Theyโ€™re available all year-round, some of the specialty pies come frozen. Order at fogartysrestaurant.net/takehomedessert.

A Southern Girl Bakery | Portsmouth 

Details: 2800 Lafayette Road, Portsmouth, 603-205-5499, sgirlbakery.com 

A Southern Girl Bakery is offering a pie that it says is โ€œthe epitome of fallโ€™s warm, cozy flavors.โ€ Its deep dish sweet potato pie surely has a southern accent. Its website describes it as โ€œa smooth, sweet blend of spiced sweet potatoes baked into a buttery crust.โ€ The bakery is also offering take and bake blueberry, cherry, blackberry and apple pies, with gluten-free and vegan versions. Thereโ€™s also peach cobbler and blackberry cobbler. Order at sgirlbakery.com by 5 p.m. on Nov. 14 and pick up on Wednesday, Nov. 25 between noon to 2 p.m.

Galley Hatch | Hamptonย 

Details: 325 Lafayette Road, Hampton, 603-926-6152, galleyhatch.com 

The Galley Hatchโ€™s Thanksgiving market is open again this year with to-go dinners, sides and baked goods though the restaurant itself will be closed on Thanksgiving Day. You can pre-order signature pies for $21 each and choose from pumpkin, apple, pecan, apple crumble, blueberry, key lime, cherry, chocolate cream, coconut cream and raspberry. Order online in advance or in-store at the restaurant, and pick up Nov. 24 and 25 to reheat at home so itโ€™s warm at dessert time. Deadline to order is Nov. 18 at 8 p.m. at galleyhatch.com/thanksgiving-to-go-hampton-nh. You can make an appointment to pick up between 10 a.m. and 7 p.m. on Nov. 24 or 8 a.m. and 6 p.m. on Nov. 25. 

Ceres Bakery | Portsmouthย 

Details:  51 Penhallow St., Portsmouth, 603-436-6518, ceresbakery.com 

Ceres Bakery is baking up special order, scratch-made pies for its 46th Thanksgiving season. Itโ€™s offering โ€œa beautiful, fat, old-fashioned, two-crustedโ€ apple pie, according to its website, as well as a blueberry pie with โ€œmillions of tiny, sweet Maine blueberries, with a bit of lemon, cinnamon and sugarโ€ in the mix. It says its pecan pie is โ€œa beauty that is sweet and filled with pecan halvesโ€ and its pumpkin pie is โ€œa rich, smooth traditional custard pie.โ€ Clearly, they love their pies, and you will, too. Place orders by phone at 603-436-6518 or by email at ceresbakeryportsmouth@gmail.com by 2 p.m. on Nov. 20 and include the type of pie, first and last name of person picking up order, a phone number, whether theyโ€™ll pick up on Tuesday, Nov. 24 or Wednesday, Nov. 25 between 8 a.m. and 2 p.m. both days. See all the breads, sides and desserts available at ceresbakery.com/sweets/holiday-specials. 

Ginger Fox Bakery | Stratham 

Details: 100 Portsmouth Ave., Stratham, 603-772-8432, gingerfoxbakery.com 

If you like a tall, fruit-filled pie, the Ginger Fox Bakery is thinking of you. In its 2026 Thanksgiving collection, it is offering a mile high apple pie alongside its pumpkin and pecan pies. Thereโ€™s also a sweet potato cashew cheesecake for something different. Pre-order by Nov. 22 and pick up at the bakery during the pickup window you choose on Nov. 24 and 25.  

Elephantine Bakery | Portsmouth 

Details: 10 Commercial Alley No. 2, Portsmouth, 603-319-6189, elephantinebakery.com 

If youโ€™re a fan of meringue, you can choose from a cranberry meringue pie or a pumpkin meringue pie at Elephantine Bakery in Portsmouth. Theyโ€™re also baking up classic pecan pies. Preorder on their website and be sure to choose the Portsmouth location if you live locally (there’s also a Boston location), then pick it up at the bakery on Wednesday, Nov. 25 between 11 a.m. and 3 p.m. 

Wallingford Farm | Kennebunk, Maine 

Details: 21 York St., Kennebunk, 207-985-2112, wallingfordfarm.com/bakery 

Wallingford Farmโ€™s reputation for delicious pies stretches far and wide. Apple, Boston cream, blueberry, caramel apple walnut, cherry, chocolate french silk, coconut cream, dutch apple, key lime, lemon meringue, fruits of the forest (apples, rhubarb, strawberries, raspberries and blackberries), peach praline, raspberry, strawberry rhubarb, and the very berry (strawberries, blackberries, raspberries and blueberries) as well as the seasonally available apple, cranberry, pecan and pumpkin pies are available. If youโ€™re not hosting a big crowd, they also sell half-pies in blueberry, apple, strawberry rhubarb and pumpkin. Order by Nov. 22 at wallingfordbakery.com for pickup through Nov. 25. 

Three Sisters Cake Shop | Doverย 

Details: 1 Washington St., Suite 3142, Dover, 603-834-9978, threesisterscakeshop.com 

Three Sisters Cake Shop in the Washington Street Mills in Dover is offering six different pies for pre-order for Thanksgiving. If youโ€™re looking for a confection thatโ€™s a little different, theyโ€™re offering their dulce de leche banana cream pie, creme brulee Boston cream pie and pumpkin cloud pie as well as its signature chocolate cream pie, classic apple pie and coconut cream pie. The banana, Boston, chocolate and coconut cream pies are all available gluten-free. Order by Nov. 20 for pickup at their mill location on Nov. 25 between 9 a.m. and 4 p.m.

Mezzanine Catering | Dover 

Details: 9 Progress Drive, Dover, 870-682-3137, mezzaninecatering.com 

Mezzanine Catering is cooking up a storm with its Thanksgiving dinner and add-ons menus, which includes pies you can order a la carte or with a full dinner. There are classic apple, spiced pumpkin, black bottom coconut cream, bourbon pecan, chocolate cream and an apple crisp to choose from. The coconut and chocolate cream are available gluten free and the crisp is available gluten-free and dairy-free. Order by Nov. 19 at mezzaninecatering.square.site. You can pick up between 4 and 5 p.m. on Nov. 25 and 10 and 11 a.m. on Thanksgiving Day, Nov. 25. 

Applecrest Farm Orchard | Hampton Falls 

Details: 133 Exeter Road, Hampton Falls, 603-926-3721, applecrest.com 

Applecrest offers a wide variety of pies including a five fruit pie, which is a sweetened mixture of strawberries, apples, rhubarb, blackberries and raspberries, just perfect for your Thanksgiving feast. Thereโ€™s also a peach raspberry pie, a mince pie or a cranapple pie for something a little different in addition to strawberry rhubarb, raspberry, peach, pumpkin, pecan, cherry, apple and blueberry and Boston cream. If youโ€™re in a crisp mood, they have two of those, too, in apple or cranapple. The pies come frozen when you pick them up and Applecrest includes pie baking instructions for each type of pie. Place your order by Nov. 22 at applecrest-farms.square.site. 

Potterโ€™s House Bakery and Cafe, Rochester 

Details: 10 Chestnut Hill Road, Rochester, 603-948-1229, pottershousebakeryandcafe.com

Potterโ€™s Bakery is offering holiday dessert and meat pies to pre-order. There are 14 dessert pies to choose from: apple, pumpkin, blueberry, Boston cream, cherry, pecan, banana cream, lemon meringue, chocolate cream, coconut cream, Dutch apple, strawberry rhubarb, Key Lime and Tollhouse. Thereโ€™s a choice of pork or chicken pot pie for a main course, too. Pre-order by Nov. 22 to pick up on Nov. 24 and 25. You can place an order at (603) 948-1229 or at pottershousebakeryandcafe.com. 

Genoโ€™s Chowder and Sandwich Shop | Portsmouthย 

Details: 177 Mechanic St., Portsmouth, 603-437-2070, genoschowder.org 

Genoโ€™s is just not for chowder anymore. The restaurant is currently closed for the season, but is taking orders for blueberry, apple and pumpkin pies through Nov. 23. The pre-ordered pies can be picked up on Wednesday, Nov. 25 between 10 a.m. and 2 p.m. Call 603-427-2070 and leave your name, number and order. 

Bearded Baking Company | Hamptonย 

Details: 580 Lafayette Road, Hampton, 603-601-6878, beardedbaking.com 

Bearded Baking Company is celebrating the holiday with pies for pre-order including its apple crumb, blueberry crumb, chocolate cream, pumpkin, pecan and banana cream. When you go to their website to order, you may not be able to leave with just a pie however. Theyโ€™re also offering an apple cider donut cake, described as apple cider donut cake layers rolled in cinnamon sugar, filled and frosted with brown sugar buttercream and topped with apple pie filling, apple chips and a cinnamon stick. Order online (no orders taken by phone or in person) at beardedbaking.com/holidaymenu for pickup on Nov. 24 and 25 between 8 a.m. and 4 p.m. 

Aubreyโ€™s on Central | Doverย 

Details: 376 Central Ave., Dover, 603-605-4906, aubreyscoffeehouse.com 

Though not open yet on Central Avenue in Dover, Aubreyโ€™s is offering chocolate cream pies as well as a gluten-free version along with several other dessert options to pre-order for the Thanksgiving holiday. To place an order, text 603-605-4906 with your name, what youโ€™d like to order and if youโ€™ll be paying with cash or Venmo. Orders must be placed by Nov. 17. Pickup is on Nov. 25 between 2 and 4 p.m. at Aubreyโ€™s home commercial kitchen in Rollinsford. If that time doesnโ€™t work for you, let her know and sheโ€™ll work out another time.  

Golden Harvest Market | Kittery, Maine

Details: 47 State Road, Kittery, 207-439-2113, goldenharvestkittery@gmail.com, and on Facebook 

The pies at Golden Harvest Produce Market in Kittery are made by baker Maryann Kane of Eliot. You canโ€™t pre-order one, but on the Monday and Tuesday of Thanksgiving week, sheโ€™ll be delivering pies several times each day. You can stop in and hopefully be one of the lucky ones to purchase one of her pies. Be forewarned also that thereโ€™s no โ€œholdingโ€ of a certain pie for a customer. You have to get โ€˜em while you can. They are available all year long, too. 

This article originally appeared on Portsmouth Herald. Reporting by Jane Murphy, Special to Seacoastonline.

Related: Thanksgiving in New Hampshire: Where to order from or dine in

Keep Granite Post free for everyone

If you found this story useful, would you consider supporting Granite Post?

Every day, our team works to provide New Hampshirites with free, fact-based reporting about the issues, policies, and decisions shaping life across the state. We believe everyone deserves access to trustworthy local newsโ€”not just those who can afford a subscription.

That's why you'll never hit a paywall here (though we may ask you to sign up for our newsletter). But keeping our journalism free depends on readers who believe informed communities are worth investing in.

If our reporting has helped you better understand what's happening in New Hampshire, please consider making a donation today. Every contribution helps us continue reporting, informing, and serving communities across the state.

Colin Booth
Colin Booth Chief Political Correspondent
Support our team