Politics

NH Dems could replace the Republican who runs state elections

With new majorities, Democrats have the votes to replace Scanlan on Dec. 2. First they have to pick one candidate.

Photo of the NH State House
Democrats now control the New Hampshire Legislature, which elects the secretary of state, and several are lining up to replace Republican David Scanlan. (Colin Booth)

New Hampshire Democrats have a rare shot at the office that runs the stateโ€™s elections, and a crowded field is lining up for it.

At least three Democrats are seeking to replace Republican Secretary of State David Scanlan, who has held the job since 2022.

Voters donโ€™t pick the secretary of state in New Hampshire. The Legislature does, and all 424 lawmakers will vote on Dec. 2.

After this monthโ€™s election, Democrats hold almost 300 of the 400 House seats and 15 of 24 Senate seats. That gives them the votes to choose a new secretary if they unite behind one candidate.

The jobโ€™s biggest duty is running elections. The office also oversees the insurance pools towns and school districts use, registers businesses and keeps the state archives.

How will Democrats pick?

The New Hampshire Democratic Party plans to hold two forums and then a straw poll, according to a source close to the party. Lawmakers in the caucus are expected to back the winner, leaving one Democrat to face Scanlan.

Who is running?

Carleigh Beriont is a Hampton Select Board member who ran for the Democratic nomination in the 1st Congressional District this year. She wants more young people registered, noting just 7% of New Hampshireโ€™s 18-year-olds are, according to The Civics Center.

Sheโ€™d also push lawmakers to make voting easier and to give the job of drawing voting districts to a nonpartisan panel. Lawmakers draw those district maps themselves now. Only the Legislature can make either change.

โ€œI think that if the people of New Hampshire have told us anything over the last week, itโ€™s that we need a new generation of people in power,โ€ Beriont told the New Hampshire Bulletin.

James Butler of Portsmouth is a former policy adviser to then-Gov. Maggie Hassan and now works for Eversource. He argues Scanlan left local officials unprepared for a large Democratic turnout in Septemberโ€™s primary.

Butler told the New Hampshire Bulletin he decided to run after local election officials said they want โ€œbetter collaboration, more professionalism out of the office and better preparedness.โ€

Over the weekend, Butler picked up the endorsement of 603 Forward, a leadership development organization in the state that targets young talent, citing his clear vision for the future of the office.

State Rep. Patrick N. Long is a Manchester attorney and Iraq War veteran who has done election protection work for Democrats since 2008. He is not the Manchester state senator of the same name.

Long wants to undo how Scanlan handled student IDs at the polls. A state law took college IDs off the list of IDs voters can show to prove who they are. Scanlan then told local election officials they could not accept a student ID for any purpose. Long argues it still allows them for voters with no other ID.

A federal judge agreed and blocked Scanlanโ€™s directive in October, but the US Supreme Court left it in place because the election was too close. Long said he would reverse it on day one.

โ€œIt could just be that he doesnโ€™t understand the law, but peopleโ€™s voting rights are affected by that,โ€ Long told the New Hampshire Bulletin.

Who else might run?

Sarah Chadzynski, a nonprofit director from Lyndeborough who ran against Beriont in this yearโ€™s 1st Congressional District Democratic primary, told the Bulletin she is โ€œseriously considering it.โ€ She told NHPR she โ€œwas asked to consider it.โ€ 

Former state Senate President Donna Soucy has also confirmed she may run, NHPR reported. Soucy, a Manchester Democrat, spent 12 years in the Senate and led it from 2018 to 2020 .

What does Scanlan say?

Scanlan spent 20 years as deputy to Bill Gardner, a Democrat who held the job for 46 years.

โ€œThere is no candidate that has anywhere near the experience that I have in this job,โ€ Scanlan told the New Hampshire Bulletin. He also enjoys the support of Republican Gov. Kelly Ayotte.

โ€œI just think that it would be the wrong thing to do to politicize the Secretary of Stateโ€™s Office,โ€ Ayotte told reporters Tuesday. Ayotte has stacked the New Hampshire state government with her own partisan political appointees, including her former campaign attorney, Bryan Gould. 

Scanlan is also under federal criminal investigation for refusing to hand President Donald Trumpโ€™s Justice Department New Hampshireโ€™s voter data. That standoff could help Scanlan with Democrats, since he has spent more than a year refusing the Trump administrationโ€™s demands.

Chatter among New Hampshire Democrats about the race tends towards concerns that some House members may back Scanlan over a Democrat. When Democrats tried to unseat him in 2022, Scanlan beat former Democratic state Sen. Melanie Levesque 237 to 175, even though the House was almost evenly split.

Why does it matter?

Republican-passed laws have made New Hampshire one of the hardest states to vote in the country. In 2022, it was ranked the hardest by the Cost of Voting Index, an academic study published in the Election Law Journal.

That ranking pointed to the stateโ€™s lack of vote by mail and early voting, and its voter ID laws.

Scanlan said the study doesnโ€™t paint an accurate picture of New Hampshireโ€™s elections.

Keep Granite Post free for everyone

If you found this story useful, would you consider supporting Granite Post?

Every day, our team works to provide New Hampshirites with free, fact-based reporting about the issues, policies, and decisions shaping life across the state. We believe everyone deserves access to trustworthy local newsโ€”not just those who can afford a subscription.

That's why you'll never hit a paywall here (though we may ask you to sign up for our newsletter). But keeping our journalism free depends on readers who believe informed communities are worth investing in.

If our reporting has helped you better understand what's happening in New Hampshire, please consider making a donation today. Every contribution helps us continue reporting, informing, and serving communities across the state.

Colin Booth
Colin Booth Chief Political Correspondent
Support our team

Categories: ,

Authors

  • Based in Manchester, Colin Booth is Granite Post’s political correspondent. A Granite State native and veteran political professional with a deep background in journalism, he’s worked on campaigns and programs in battleground states across the country, ranging from New Hampshire, Texas, Pennsylvania and Washington D.C.