News

Analysis: NH GOP lost big. Here’s their plan to get power back

New Hampshire Republicans are pissed off. They campaigned for Donald Trump, held his signs and knocked doors for him. They worked to be his face, his voice and his hand in New Hampshire. They became Donald Trump, and they expected Donald Trump results. Instead, on Nov. 3, voters across the state punished them for trying…

They campaigned as Donald Trump’s voice in New Hampshire, and voters punished them for it. Expect tax lies, Trump amnesia and a lot of accusations of socialism. (Colin Booth)

New Hampshire Republicans are pissed off.

They campaigned for Donald Trump, held his signs and knocked doors for him. They worked to be his face, his voice and his hand in New Hampshire. They became Donald Trump, and they expected Donald Trump results.

Instead, on Nov. 3, voters across the state punished them for trying to be Donald Trump.

Democrats won what the Union Leader called the biggest Democratic House majority ever, flipped seven state Senate seats and the entire executive council.

“We have never had this many Democrats elected,” House Democratic Leader Alexis Simpson told the New Hampshire Bulletin.

The funny thing is, nearly every Republican in New Hampshire is now saying they think this election, for which Trump was not on the ballot, had everything to do with Trump and nothing to do with them at all.

Now Republicans are embittered. They think the voters made a mistake. Outgoing US House Speaker Mike Johnson said it out loud, telling CNN, “I’m sorry that the voters made the wrong choice.”

So what happens when an angry party lands in the minority?

They’re not tearing up the playbook.

Since 1923, Republicans have held a majority in the House for 94 years. Democrats have held it for 10.

New Hampshire Republicans feel like they have been pretty successful at running the same playbook for decades and decades, and there’s no reason to think they’re going to tear it up even after the shellacking they took this month.

So here’s what you can expect.

Everything’s an income tax

Republicans in New Hampshire have always manipulated the definition of what constitutes a tax to best fit their political situation, especially when it comes to the idea of income taxes.

Now it’s to their advantage to stretch that definition as wide as possible.

If a bill comes before the Legislature that has money involved, it’s going to be a tax. Everything is going to be an income tax.

The most recent and highest-profile example of this is their repeal of the Interest and Dividends Tax. A tax levied on investment returns in a percentage that only meaningfully touched the absolute wealthiest individuals in the state.

Republicans disingenuously labeled it a broad-based income tax. These are policies nobody anywhere else in the world calls an income tax. But here, Republicans will not only label them as such, but present them as if they affect the entire population, because that’s the playbook.

And these choices are highly situational.

In 2025 when Governor Kelly Ayotte and the Republican Legislature added monthly premiums for people on Medicaid—among the lowest-income individuals in the state—somehow that was not considered a tax by state Republicans.

And that same year when Republican lawmakers created and/or raised 58 new state fees to make up for their cuts—fees overwhelmingly levied on blue-collar workers for things like registrations for tractors and cement mixers—those were not considered an income tax, even though they clearly came from the income of working people.

Now they’re going to triple down, and any and every new source of state revenue will be called an income tax.

Trump? Never heard of him

Republicans will keep pretending Trump doesn’t exist.

John Sununu modeled this in his U.S. Senate race. It didn’t work. But he got such an inordinate amount of credit from conservative media and Republican news outlets that others will likely copy his behavior.

Expect a lot of state lawmakers who spent two years running the Legislature like Trump, using his language, to suddenly forget his name, pretend they never wore the MAGA hats, never knocked doors for him, didn’t defend him and his policies on social media. They want a fresh start.

Everyone’s a socialist (or a communist)

Made it this far in the article? Guess what, that’s more than enough for New Hampshire Republicans to call you a socialist.

NH GOP leaders couldn’t make the label stick to candidates at the top of the ticket this year, but that didn’t stop them from trying, and the incoming NH GOP House minority leader has a particular affinity for calling his political opponents communists.

Republican polling and focus groups have found the label works as an empty boogeyman-phrase largely devoid of meaning, so expect it to get thrown around a lot.

The new Legislature takes office in January.

Keep Granite Post free for everyone

If you found this story useful, would you consider supporting Granite Post?

Every day, our team works to provide New Hampshirites with free, fact-based reporting about the issues, policies, and decisions shaping life across the state. We believe everyone deserves access to trustworthy local news—not just those who can afford a subscription.

That's why you'll never hit a paywall here (though we may ask you to sign up for our newsletter). But keeping our journalism free depends on readers who believe informed communities are worth investing in.

If our reporting has helped you better understand what's happening in New Hampshire, please consider making a donation today. Every contribution helps us continue reporting, informing, and serving communities across the state.

Colin Booth
Colin Booth Chief Political Correspondent
Support our team

Categories:

Authors

  • Based in Manchester, Colin Booth is Granite Post’s political correspondent. A Granite State native and veteran political professional with a deep background in journalism, he’s worked on campaigns and programs in battleground states across the country, ranging from New Hampshire, Texas, Pennsylvania and Washington D.C.